How to Sell a Rental Property with Bad Tenants in Birmingham, Alabama

Selling a rental property is already a challenge, but selling one with bad tenants? That's a different beast. In Birmingham, Alabama, landlords sometimes find themselves stuck between a rock and a hard place.

Whether you're dealing with late payments, property damage, or uncooperative renters, there is a path forward. Birmingham Homebuyers, LLC has helped dozens of Birmingham property owners sell quickly, even with difficult tenants in place.

In this blog, we'll break down exactly how to sell a rental property with bad tenants in Birmingham, AL, and how to do it without stress, delays, or surprises.

Get Your Free Cash Offer Now!

Fill out this form to get your no-obligation all cash offer started!

Get Your Free Offer TODAY!

Fill In This Form To Get Your No-Obligation All Cash Offer Started!

"*" indicates required fields

This field is for validation purposes and should be left unchanged.

SEOREI - AI Lease Agreement 12

Understanding Your Legal Rights as a Landlord in Birmingham, AL

Before making any moves, it's important to understand the tenant laws in Birmingham.

Alabama law tends to favor landlords, but that doesn't mean you can act recklessly. The Alabama Uniform Residential Landlord and Tenant Act outlines the rights and responsibilities of both parties.

Here are a few important things to keep in mind:

  • You can sell a property even if it's tenant-occupied, but the lease terms remain in effect for the new owner unless otherwise agreed upon.
  • Tenants must be given appropriate notice (typically 30 days) if you're asking them to vacate.
  • You can't evict a tenant without cause unless they're on a month-to-month lease or you include a sale clause in the lease agreement.

The 3 Main Options to Sell a Rental Property with Bad Tenants

When you've got problematic tenants in your Birmingham property, here are your three main options:

1. Wait Until the Lease Ends

This is the cleanest route, but not always realistic. If you can afford to wait until the lease is up, and the tenant moves out, you'll have full control to sell the property vacant.

However, if the tenants are damaging the property or missing rent payments, this option could cost you more than you'll gain.

2. Try Cash for Keys

Cash for keys is a common strategy where you offer tenants a financial incentive to leave the property early and in good condition. It may feel strange to pay someone who's already causing you stress, but it can be quicker and cheaper than a drawn-out eviction process.

Make sure to get any agreement in writing and confirm move-out terms to protect yourself legally.

3. Sell the Property As-Is to a Cash Buyer

If the property is in rough shape, or your tenants refuse to cooperate, this is the fastest and least stressful route. Real estate investors who buy properties for cash in Birmingham, Alabama are familiar with these situations. They'll often buy your property with the tenants still inside.

This means no delays, no repairs, and no more property management headaches. You can learn more about how this works by visiting our How It Works page.

What Types of Bad Tenants Can Still Be Sold With the Property?

We've worked with properties that had:

  • Tenants behind on rent for 3+ months
  • Lease violations (like unauthorized pets or occupants)
  • Consistent property damage
  • Hoarder-level clutter
  • Police reports or complaints

The good news? You can still sell the house. Cash buyers in Birmingham, AL often specialize in buying these exact types of distressed rental properties.

In fact, many investors are open to buying homes that have even deeper issues, like code violations or structural damage, which may be holding up a traditional sale.

SEOREI - AI We buy houses in 8

See What Other Homeowners in Birmingham, Alabama Are Saying

We’ve bought countless houses from homeowners, making the process quick and stress-free.. Here’s what they had to say about working with Birmingham Homebuyers, LLC:

Birmingham Home Buyers - 5 Stars

I recently sold my house to Birmingham Homebuyers. The people were friendly and helpful. My house needed some work done, and I couldn’t afford to make repairs. Frank went out and looked at it and had inspections and came back with an offer. We started the process December 23rd and closed January 25th. I had a very good experience with them!

Customer Feedback - Karen Dodson - Birmingham Homebuyers, LLC

Karen Dodson

Birmingham, AL

Birmingham Home Buyers - 5 Stars

I had a wonderful experience with Birmingham Homebuyers LLC I needed to sell my property in Alabama and Mr. Frank Powell was very helpful through the entire process. Even though I was living out of state I was able to get the process completed without any problems. Thank you so much Birmingham Homebuyers LLC

Customer Feedback - Tiffany Walace - Birmingham Homebuyers, LLC

Tiffany Wallace

Birmingham, AL

Birmingham Home Buyers - 5 Stars

The team at Birmingham Homebuyers LLC is very professional. I have bought and sold several homes, and this by far is the best group of people that I have dealt with. They make the selling process very efficient, which lessens the stress on the seller. I highly recommend this company to anyone looking to sell or buy a home.

Customer Feedback - Hudson Harris - Birmingham Homebuyers, LLC

Hudson Harris

Birmingham, AL

Get Your Free Cash Offer Now!

Get Your Free Offer TODAY!

Fill In This Form To Get Your No-Obligation All Cash Offer Started!

"*" indicates required fields

This field is for validation purposes and should be left unchanged.

SEOREI - AI Tired owner 12

Why Traditional Buyers and Realtors Won't Touch Tenant-Occupied Rentals

Listing your property on the MLS through a traditional real estate agent usually requires that the home is "show-ready." That's nearly impossible when you have:

  • Uncooperative tenants who won't allow showings
  • Unsafe or unsanitary conditions
  • Leases that lock in below-market rent

Traditional buyers want a turnkey experience. Most don't want to inherit problem tenants or take on eviction duties.

Trying to push a timeline, especially when you're in a bind, often leads sellers to wonder: Can you really sell your Birmingham house in 7 days? The answer depends heavily on your route.

This is where direct cash home buyers in Birmingham, Alabama provide a real solution.

Benefits of Selling to a Cash Home Buyer in Birmingham

Selling your rental to a local cash buyer like Birmingham Homebuyers, LLC means:

  • No agent fees or commissions
  • No showings, repairs, or clean-outs
  • You can sell with tenants in place
  • Close in as little as 7 to 14 days
  • You get a fair all-cash offer, no waiting on financing

Local cash buyers understand the Birmingham rental market, especially areas like Ensley, East Lake, Center Point, and Bessemer. They'll evaluate the property and give you a fast solution, tenant drama included.

That said, it's important to separate fact from fiction. When talking about direct sales, many people still believe outdated cash offer myths that no longer apply in today's investor-driven market.

What If the Tenants Refuse to Leave?

If your tenants are actively refusing to leave, even after cash for keys or proper notice, you have two main options:

Legal Eviction

It's not ideal, but sometimes necessary. Alabama's eviction process requires a 7-day notice for nonpayment of rent or a 14-day notice for lease violations. From there, you'll need to file an unlawful detainer action in district court.

Sell Anyway

Many cash buyers in Birmingham will still buy your property, even if you're mid-eviction. Just be upfront about the situation so they can factor it into their offer. You can even sell if your house is in the probate process.

SEOREI - AI Tired owner 6

How to Get a Fair All-Cash Offer for Your Birmingham Rental

Getting an offer is simple. Here's what you'll need:

  • Property address
  • Photos (if possible)
  • Basic info about the tenants (lease term, payment history, known issues)

Once you submit those details to a reputable investor or home-buying company in Birmingham, Alabama, you'll often get a fair all-cash offer within 24 hours.
From there, you can pick your closing date and move forward.

Get Your Free Cash Offer Now!

Fill out this form to get your no-obligation all cash offer started!

Get Your Free Offer TODAY!

Fill In This Form To Get Your No-Obligation All Cash Offer Started!

"*" indicates required fields

This field is for validation purposes and should be left unchanged.

TJ Sayers - Owner - Birmingham Homebuyers, LLC

Don't Let Bad Tenants Keep You Stuck

Owning rental property in Birmingham should be a source of income, not constant stress. If you're tired of the missed payments, maintenance nightmares, or nonstop phone calls from tenants, it might be time to move on.

Sell your house fast in Birmingham and skip the hassle of evictions, clean-outs, and showings. Whether your tenants are months behind or just won't cooperate, a fair all-cash offer could be the relief you've been waiting for.